logo (3)

Teacher Shortage Brings Retired Educators Back to School

Empty Classroom

You have probably dreamed of spending your retirement time traveling or simply waking up later and relaxing in front of the TV. That’s fair. Upon reaching that point, you suddenly come across the nationwide teacher shortage issue and for this reason, you decided to return to the classroom. If it is true or might become a reality in the near future in your case, we’ve come-up with some important things for you to consider.

In this article, you’ll get to know:

  • Key factors of teacher shortage in the U.S.
  • The role of retired educators to overcome the current teacher shortage crisis across the U.S.
  • Concerns about losing pension benefits and earning a full salary while returning back to teaching.

Addressing the Teacher Shortage

According to data published by Kansas City University, there are over 55,000 vacant positions for teachers in the U.S. and 270,000 unqualified positions as schools continue to keep their classrooms staffed. Retired Educators are in the best position to bridge this gap because of their knowledge, experience and skills. Teaching is a life-long occupation. and having retired teachers back in the classroom can also help keep the minds and bodies of the retirees active.

Some of the factors for teacher shortages in the U.S. include:

Evolving Career Preferences:

As more teachers look towards more lucrative opportunities, leveraging on skills they have already built. This became a trend across the States, where more teachers are exploring career opportunities outside of traditional teaching roles.

Many teachers develop a diverse skill set that goes beyond teaching-specific abilities, such as communication, leadership, and organization. As a result, they may be attracted to other professions where they can leverage these skills and potentially earn higher salaries.

According to a mentorship platform, some teachers are transitioning into roles specifically in educational technology (edtech) and curriculum development, where their teaching experience can be plausible and valuable. Additional data points to educators looking for opportunities in fields unrelated to education, such as business, marketing, or healthcare.

This evolving career preference among teachers reflects a broader trend of individuals seeking to maximize their earning potential and explore new opportunities that align with their skill set and interests.

It also highlights one of the main causes of the current crisis: the benefits offered to teachers, which, despite the sense of vocation, have been insufficient in the country. For instance, to support this claim, it is a fact that approximately 40% of public school teachers do not have Social Security coverage.

Teacher Burnout:

Teacher burnout is a significant issue in the United States, exacerbated by various factors including the threat of terrorist attacks and the challenges posed by the COVID-19 pandemic.

Teaching has always been recognized as a demanding profession, requiring dedication, passion, and resilience to navigate the complexities of educating students effectively. However, in recent years, teachers have faced heightened stressors that have contributed to increased levels of burnout.

Violence, especially the threat of terrorist attacks has created an atmosphere of fear and uncertainty in schools across the country. Teachers are not only responsible for educating their students but also for ensuring their safety and well-being. The constant need to be vigilant and prepared for emergencies can take a toll on teachers’ mental and emotional well-being, leading to heightened levels of stress and burnout.

Additionally, the COVID-19 pandemic (as we will address in more detail below) has brought unprecedented challenges to the education system. Teachers have had to adapt quickly to remote learning environments, navigate technological challenges, and support students who may be experiencing heightened levels of anxiety and uncertainty. The shift to remote teaching has blurred the boundaries between work and home life, making it difficult for teachers to disconnect and recharge.

Reduction in Certified Teachers:

The reduction in certified teachers in North America is an older and ongoing issue that has been prevalent for some time. This decline refers to a decrease in the number of qualified and certified educators available to meet the demands of the education system in North America.

Several factors contribute to this reduction. One significant reason is the number of individuals entering the teaching profession due to various reasons, including low salaries, challenging work conditions, and limited opportunities for career advancement.

To give an idea of the state of teacher preparation, between the 2008-09 and the 2018-19 school years, the number of individuals completing a teacher education program dropped by nearly one-third, as reported by The American Association of Colleges for Teacher Education.

Furthermore, as aforementioned, budget constraints and funding cuts in education have led to the elimination of teaching positions and the consolidation of schools, resulting in fewer job opportunities for educators.

The reduction in certified teachers has significant implications for the current crisis, impacting on larger class sizes, increased workload for existing teachers and challenges in providing quality education to students.

Overall, the reduction in certified teachers is a major issue that requires attention and real action from policymakers. Addressing this problem requires comprehensive strategies to implement policies to support teacher recruitment and retention efforts.

The Impact of the Pandemic

The pandemic only worsened this existing and enduring shortage of teachers, which is especially pronounced in specific subject areas and regions.

During that period, teachers experienced unprecedented levels of stress. According to the Rand Corporation’s 2021 State of the US Teacher Survey, nearly one in four teachers expressed a likelihood of leaving their jobs by the end of the 2020-2021 school year. This is a significant increase compared to the average turnover rate before the pandemic, where only one in six teachers were considering leaving their positions.

The JOLTS vacancy data also indicate a significant surge in monthly vacancy rates throughout the pandemic. Since 2020, the vacancy rate has averaged 2.7%, markedly higher than the 1.7% rate observed until 2019, and more than 2.5 times the 1.1% rate recorded for the period from 2001 to 2012.

In addition to stress, the observation of students’ poor performance added another layer of pressure and frustration for school professionals, many of whom were required to quickly master technological resources.

According to a survey conducted by Harvard, children have resumed learning, but largely at the same pace as before the pandemic. CEPR faculty director Thomas Kane remarked, “There’s no hurrying up teaching fractions or the Pythagorean theorem.” He highlighted the challenge faced by the hardest-hit communities, such as Richmond, Virginia, St. Louis, Missouri, and New Haven, Connecticut, where students fell behind by more than 1.5 years in math. These communities would need to teach 150 percent of a typical year’s worth of material for three consecutive years just to catch up.

Kane emphasized that this would require a significant increase in instructional time. He suggested that any district that lost more than a year of learning should be required to revisit their recovery plans.

However, the researchers argue that schools were not solely responsible for the decline in achievement. They also assert that schools alone can not provide the solution. Returning to normalcy might be appealing, but doing so would only perpetuate the pandemic’s devastating impact on inequality. At this stage, students who are not on the regular school calendar require academic content in summer camps and after-school programs, which could further strain teachers.

National Teacher Shortage

The “national teacher shortage” is actually older and more extensive than commonly believed. The monthly quit rates in the JOLTS data for all public education also indicate that an increasing proportion of workers in the sector were resigning from their positions each month even prior to the pandemic.

A 2013 survey carried out by Gallup-Healthways Well-Being Index revealed that 46% of K–12 teachers reported experiencing “stress during most of the day” shortly before being interviewed by the researchers.

Additionally, various other sources suggest that before the pandemic, the levels of stress among teachers were on par with or exceeded those found in other professions, including occupations known for their challenging work conditions.

Once more, benefits emerge as the primary incentive for continued recruitment and retention within the K-12 workforce. More specific concerns such as pension benefits, crucial for ensuring retirement stability for teachers, are weighed by professionals considering leaving the field of education.

Could Retired Teachers Be the Solution to Shortages in the US?

Numerous retired educators are returning to classrooms, as school officials are reaching out to them to fill the positions they once held.

Julia Acosta is a good example. She had recently retired from her beloved career as a teacher in Jacksonville, Florida. With retirement, came the joy of welcoming her first grandchild, a moment she had eagerly anticipated.

However, one evening, while watching the news, teacher Acosta stumbled upon a report highlighting the alarming shortage of teachers in the country. Despite her retirement, she couldn’t shake the feeling that she still had more to give to the next generation, a sense of duty to overcome the prevalent crisis.

But it wasn’t just altruism that motivated Acosta’s decision to return to teaching. Financial concerns weighed heavily on her as well. She could not only contribute to her daughter’s financial stability but also provide a better future for her grandson.

Mrs. Acosta embarked on a new chapter in her life, returning to the classroom not just for herself, but for the sake of future generations and the ones she loved.

This is one of several cases pointing to the rehiring of retired educators as one of the most efficient alternatives in response to the current teacher shortage problem in the country.

In 2022, an analysis revealed that at least six states have either passed or are contemplating legislation this year to encourage retired teachers to return to the workforce.

Traditionally, each state has had regulations limiting the amount of work or income retired educators could have while receiving retirement benefits. However, many of these new laws are loosening those restrictions due to shortages, as reported by a magazine in the segment.

This data also highlights the fact that this tactic of recruiting retired teachers was previously implemented during periods of high teacher vacancies.

Questions about Losing Benefits from Pension and Earning a Full Salary – A probable game-changer?

Retired teachers who wish to return to the classroom need to be keenly aware of local laws regarding potential loss or temporary reduction of pension and benefits, as each state has autonomy in this matter.

In New York, retired teachers generally lose their pension payments if they return to work and earn a salary exceeding $35,000. However, the state lifted the income cap in 2022.

On the other hand, states like Missouri have signed permanent new legislations to address teacher shortages by incentivizing retirees to return to the classroom. These laws allow educators to resume work without sacrificing retirement benefits.

In New Mexico, the governor approved a law enabling retired teachers to re-enter the classroom for an additional three years, with particular provisions that include no restrictions on salary or working hours.

It is important to note that these changes in state laws have been signed into effect after the pandemic. Also, it is essential that State policymakers start to acknowledge that this approach could solve part of the needs of school districts. Sometimes, retired teachers want to continue working but lack the incentive to do so without risking their pension benefits.

Conclusion

By all means, it is a great opportunity for retired educators who are able to kick start teaching once again and return to classrooms instead of staying at home. New laws supporting the reentry of retired teachers into the classroom can benefit both educators and states. For those considering returning to teaching, whether for personal or professional reasons, there are new benefit programs designed to address this challenge.

On the same road, It would be more convenient for districts to enlist retired teachers, who are already familiar with the school environment, back into the classroom, even if only on a part-time basis, rather than seeking an entirely new workforce.

Nevertheless, some advocates suggest that this trend is once again gaining momentum among state policymakers in the wake of the pandemic, serving as a temporary solution to the ongoing teacher shortage crisis. Anyway, this approach may provide relief for school districts by placing experienced teachers in classrooms where they are urgently needed.

Do you need help overcoming your financial struggles?

We’re happy to help! Make the first step to improve your life by reaching out today.